Discernment in Modern Witchcraft: A Conservative Witch’s Guide
In a world where witchcraft trends faster than the moon cycles—hashtags, hexes, and crystal influencers everywhere—it’s easy for conservative witches to feel adrift. Modern pagan spaces often tilt progressive, centering activism over ancestry. But witchcraft’s oldest roots are deeply conservative: self-reliance, stewardship, and reverence for natural order.
This post will help you navigate modern resources with discernment, filter ideology from insight, and keep your sacred spaces safe, grounded, and genuinely yours.
The Challenge: A Progressive Tilt in Modern Paganism
Much of today’s neo-pagan literature leans left, weaving activism and radical identity politics into ritual life. For many witches, this mix can feel foreign—especially if your values prize order, personal responsibility, and family continuity.
Yet witchcraft itself isn’t solely political—it’s practical. Folk traditions across Europe and the Americas preserved community, faith, and the land through ritual rhythm, not rebellion. The conservative witch’s task is to discern the timeless from the timely.
Cultivating Discernment in Your Reading
Discernment is the witch’s sharpest blade—an ability to separate wheat from chaff in spiritual literature.
When you read a modern Wicca or pagan book:
-
Read for practice, not politics. Take note of mechanics—circle casting, correspondences, timing—not ideology.
-
Ask grounding questions:
-
Does this strengthen my sovereignty?
-
Does it align with stewardship and my core values?
-
-
Translate before rejecting. When you can, take the guidance and reframe what might not fit. Shifting the perspective might help you keep what works and transmute the rest. If what's written doesn't belong in your grimoire, discard it!
-
Keep a running notes page in your journal to distill usable elements. One simple exercise is, when you come across something you disagree with, take the time to write a note about why you disagree with it. Reaffirming your values for yourself. And if practicable, maybe add a note about how you can guard your craft from things that don't fit within your boundaries!
Discernment isn’t cynicism—it’s craftsmanship of the soul.
Exercise: Extract and Translate a Modern Text
What you’ll need: a modern witchcraft or Wicca book that you already have, your journal, and a candle.
-
Read with Intention. Light your candle and affirm:
“I seek wisdom that strengthens tradition and aligns with my values.”
Skim chapters; highlight rituals or correspondences worth testing. -
Identify Core vs. Overlay.
What’s universal (e.g., grounding meditation)? What’s ideological overlay (e.g., activist framing)? -
Translate to Traditional Values.
-
“Liberating oppressed energies” → “Protecting sacred order.”
-
“Destroying the patriarchy” → “Honoring balanced hierarchy.”
-
“Feminist goddess ritual” → “Matriarchal ancestral blessing.”
-
-
Test and Record.
Perform your adapted version. Note results and emotional tone. -
Release and Cleanse.
End with saltwater cleansing, thanking the original text for useful fragments.
This refinement process creates a faithful, values-aligned practice without discarding modern resources entirely.
I had to do this work of discernment and harvesting what I needed from a book recently. It was The Magical Writing Grimoire by Lisa Marie Basile. I would recommend the book to other writers only if it were free on kindle unlimited. I bought the paperback and I give this book 2/5 stars total.
Some of the writing exercises are really helpful and the writer's style is good. However, the content of the book goes way left into mandatory activism, and in my opinion, hyper-focuses on trauma/shadow work. If you're looking for a book to carry you through self-excavation and trauma processing through writing, then it might be worth the read. However, I didn't feel this book was deeply about the magic of writing. It was very surface level for me. Without debasing the creator's experiences, I can say this book wasn't right for me because I was looking for a book about writing, not a book solely about healing hurt through writing, and yes the two are extricable.
With shadow work, processing trauma and grief comes with the territory, and I think one section about shadow work would have sufficed. What I didn't expect was to find in a book titled, "The Magical Writing Grimoire," almost solely shadow work prompts and minimal "manifestation" writing rituals. At least, I spent the $22.99 on the paperback so you don't have to!
Cons: The book goes deeply into detail about the author's relationship to writing as a therapeutic/cathartic tool, but then veers left abruptly into mandatory community activism. It also repeatedly uses progressive language, referencing multiple genders and states of personal and political oppression. I didn't feel this was at all relevant to the magic of writing, and it felt more like someone who happens to be a writer talking about her experience and philosophies, and why writing is a tool for healing and self-exploration. Which points, in my opinion, to a larger issue: I think too often "magic" is conflated with general spirituality, and this seems to be a modern mishandling of witchcraft.
You can have a strong, undeniably spiritual experience while making art through a cathartic medium, like writing, that helps you process trauma and heal wounds. But that isn't necessarily 'magic.' That's just the spirit responding to a spiritual experience or the mind responding to a psychological experience. If you go to therapy and work through issues through conversation with a psychologist and use mental exercises to cope--that isn't the performance of magic. It's psychologic. It can feel intensely spiritual, and people do have spiritual experiences through "shadow work" or psychotherapy. But the definition of magic, in traditional witchcraft, is the use of spells, charms, and rituals to affect change or control events. It is the ability to influence reality through belief, will, and symbolic action which sometimes involves rituals or the invocation of spiritual forces. For me, I expected a book that moved beyond believing writing could be a magical medium to actual rituals, spells, charms, and craft-related practices that were both symbolic and effective. Instead, I got a book about how someone really liked journaling and thought archetypes were interesting tools for self-exploration (which I do agree with).
Some more traditional groups distinguish magic from spirituality, but more modern groups sometimes interconnect or overlay the two. As a traditional witch, this is exactly why it is important to practice discernment and figure out what your values are. If you value a practicable craft that is symbolic and connected to a natural and supernatural spiritual system, steeped in wonder, focused on connection, intentional action, and immersive engagement, then you might align with my stance. But if you are looking for a spiritual craft that offers self-empowerment to accomplish the purpose of personal development, then you might like this book. The two are not mutually exclusive. They can overlap, but I think it's important to make the distinction or to define that for oneself, especially as a trad witch.
The other thing I've thought about while reading this book is that modern society deeply associates their spiritual identity with their political ideology. And devoid of a religious system, many people morph their philosophical or political identities into a type of spiritual system. Which isn't necessarily wrong but it does raise an interesting idea: perhaps, in modern witchcraft/paganism, community becomes that system to connect to, identity becomes a nearly-supernatural driving force to engage, and activism becomes the ritualistic, symbolic action the spirit and mind are craving. It might be a pseudo-spiritual craft. Or it might be very real. Food for thought.
Pros: The book highlights the historical power of the written word through a magical lens, offers some practicable rituals for crafting a sacred writing space and routine, and has some useful prompts that I thought were really thought provoking about creativity. However, there's nothing in this book that I could not find in others that are not as left-leaning.
Holding Your Values Close
In fast-moving spiritual spaces, hold your heart steady. You don’t need to debate to stay true—just practice with clarity. Let the loud voices scroll by; your quiet daily devotion speaks louder.
Remember: discernment is itself an act of protection. It shields your sacred hearth from confusion and keeps your magic rooted in your authentic, personal values.
Small Workings for a Safer Sacred Space
Build spiritual resilience through small, consistent acts:
-
Threshold Salt: sprinkle a pinch daily to bless and protect the home.
-
Hearth Candle: light one at dusk and pray for peace within your walls.
-
Seasonal Walks: walk your property or garden under moonlight to reaffirm stewardship.
-
Family Blessing Bowl: keep water on your altar infused with bay leaf for stability.
Each act reinforces the conservative witch’s essence: quiet power, stable ground, enduring faith.
Closing: Keep the Flame
You are not out of place—you are the keeper of a vital lineage. When you practice discernment, adapt with reverence, and hold to tradition, you help restore witchcraft’s original pulse: ordered, humble, sacred.
Light your candle tonight. Journal what feels true. Let your small magics weave safety and strength.
If you're looking for more critique content like this post, follow this blog and be my friend on Pinterest, where I aim to create bite-sized content for conservative witches who value land, love, & liberty!
